Star Island Road
Montauk , NY 11954
Dock
Offered
Mooring
Not Offered
Day Trip
Not Offered
Book faster with the free Dockwa app
61 Reviews
by Volkmann - Verified user on May 25, 2026
Such a fantastic marina! Staff is amazing and the grill restaurant is perfect! Love SIYC Marina! We will definitely be back! Mahalo!
by Fred L. - Verified user on Sep 15, 2025
Beautiful marina. Dock staff was very helpful with getting tied up and utilities connected. The woman in the main office for check in/out was super nice and extremely helpful. I can't wait to go back.
by Jack H. - Verified user on Aug 29, 2025
Excellent marina!! Staff & facilities are top notch
by Charlie C. - Verified user on Aug 25, 2025
The whole staff was very Friendly and accommodating!
by Philip T. - Verified user on Aug 17, 2025
Great staff easy no hassle that's all u need .
by Robert P. - Verified user on Aug 12, 2025
The place was very nice. However, Mike inside the store was the typical disgruntled Montauk local. Rude to the visitors. Sarcastic guy. Store was crazy expensive and he mocked people that inquired about prices. Ex: "Mike, How much are these beers" Mike: Expensive, you're in Montauk. What did you expect" Really?? This is the face of your business. Time for Mike to go out to pasture. He is not the people person this nice marina requires. Other than Mike, the place was fantastic.
by Chuck M. - Verified user on Jul 22, 2025
Great location. Awesome dock store. Great deck hands. Expensive but worth it
by William S. - Verified user on Jul 22, 2025
Perfect stop over. Good service and great amenities.
by Paul S. - Verified user on Jul 16, 2025
First time here and it was “perfect”. The docks are pristine, dockhands are ready to help with anything needed and the facilities couldn’t have been more accommodating. 2 things that amazed me was the service and the restaurant on site. My travel shore power cords were literally 6 inches too short to reach the pedestal plug. I called the front desk to ask if someone could help and in less than 5 minutes the dock master was standing behind my boat with 2 shore power cables for me to use. No questions asked. Regarding the restaurant; when arriving I always thought that the sites restaurant was more of a snack bar. It looked that way but it was far from it. Food was fantastic. I mean really really fantastic. Couldn’t believe it. Ate there 3 times. Pool was also very nice and the easy access to the water. So in short, well worth the trip and I will be back and probably this season not wanting to wait until next.
by Duane H. - Verified user on Jul 14, 2025
Always a good time staying at star Island. Clean place to stay and meet new friends out there.
by Jeffrey M. - Verified user on Jul 14, 2025
Very nice people. Had a great stay!
by Glen & Kim B. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2025
Awesome marina. Friendly people, great dock crew, great facilities. Super clean, super helpful, extremely well run!
by Brandon B. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2025
just great! love the floating docks, fillet tables, solid infrastructure, perfectly stocked store for everything from catching to eating the fish. nice people there. second year in a tow worked out perfectly.
by Anthony C. - Verified user on Jul 10, 2025
Top notch facility, great restaurant and bar, live music... The staff is amazing. Love Sam's Star Island!!
by Matthew G. - Verified user on Jul 07, 2025
Excellently maintained and located in prime location. Music on weekends and friendly staff and clean facilities.
by James B. - Verified user on Jun 15, 2025
Great and helpful staff. Love the location and floating docks.
by Richard K. - Verified user on Oct 06, 2024
No complaints… grill is excellent
by Ronni B. - Verified user on Aug 28, 2024
Excellent!! Beautiful well maintained grounds!
by Arnold G. - Verified user on Aug 27, 2024
Great friendly clean place
by Josh G. - Verified user on Aug 07, 2024
Clean, organized, lots of amenities, good restaurant. Would certainly stay there again.
by Stephen B. - Verified user on Jul 23, 2024
Staff very friendly and responsive. Dockhand was there when we pulled in and helped tie up. Property is meticulously clean and the main docks seem to be brand new (or close to it). Our kid loved the pool too.
by Steven B. - Verified user on Jul 05, 2024
Nice and low key. Everything is in excellent shape.
by Peter D. - Verified user on Jun 17, 2024
Nice place, great food, experienced staff
by Gordon D. - Verified user on Jun 01, 2024
Great marina. Awesome location, good docks and friendly staff.
by Zoltan B. - Verified user on Sep 06, 2023
Ryan and staff were very understanding and accommodating. They exhibited professionalism even late in the day when attending to three boats which arrived at once. Looking forward to next years stay there. A+ service. Thank you.
About Sam's Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
Sam's Star Island Yacht Club attracts a wide variety of people year-round with a passion for cruising and fishing. Fishermen and boaters come from all over the Island and up and down the East Coast to enjoy the excitement of seasonal sport fishing and access to an extensive fleet of charter boats. Sam's Star Island is also host to many fishing tournaments, cruising club rendezvous, and catered events, as well as Sam's Star Island’s own planned tournaments.
With its unique resemblance of a star floating on the ocean, Sam's Star Island Yacht Club has come a long way from the boat yard it once was. Sam Gershowitz and his team have turned it into a great destination for boaters on the East Coast. “It’s a beautiful place,” Gershowitz says with pride. “It’s a yacht club and a marina, and we cater to people here. It's a very comfortable place to hang around.”
No marina in the area offers more facilities and services. The Ship’s Store is one of the largest tackle shops with bait of every type, an expert staff, marine supplies including electrical, polishes and waxes, cleaning materials, marine safety equipment, boat batteries, collectors’ items, groceries, and a full repair service. Visitors can sit down for a casual breakfast, lunch and dinner at Star Island Grill, serving fresh locally caught seafood. Spend Saturday nights at Star Island Grill for live poolside music and dancing overlooking Lake Montauk and the ocean. With all it has to offer, Sam's Star Island Yacht Club is an inviting club and marina for all. We invite you to consider the possibilities at Sam's Star Island.
Booking Info
Max LOA: 165'
Max Beam: 30'
Max Draft: 12'
Boats over 90' please call marina to book reservation
Services
Amenities
Info
Photos
